Having never been to Brooklyn, I have no clue what the food is like. However, I know a good burger or pizza when I come across one. And with Brooklyn Pizza and Bistro being the talk of town since opening its doors a few weeks ago, I had to give it a go.
Setting up shop in the rapidly rising Russian Market area, the bistro is nestled on Street 123 almost directly opposite the Frangipani Hotel (a useful landmark). And catering to a craving for authentic American comfort food seems to be something the area is lacking because the joint was full when we arrived, something I’m told is often the case.
Inside the decor is simple with cream walls and tiles with Moroccan-inspired detail adding to the light and airy feel. Plenty of tables and chairs fill the spacious room, and a serving area and glass counter displaying a mouth-watering range of home-baked cheesecakes and desserts sits in one corner. Plain walls divert attention to the funky circular lampshades.
Brooklyn Pizza and Bistro serves up a healthy range of American-inspired dishes. The pizzas are made to share, coming in 12” and 16”, and range from The Godfather ($9.90/ $14.90), a mighty feast of Italian sausage, sliced meatballs, mozzarella, parmesan olives, peppers and chili flakes, to the Westside Calzone ($8.50), mozzarella, parmesan, ricotta, pepperoni and bacon. Other dishes include pasta, salad, ribs, chicken wings, sandwiches and burgers, such as the Aussie Royale ($7.50), topped with bacon, egg, cheese, pineapple and beetroot.
Although the crisp-based pizzas slathered with toppings looked to die for, it was the BBQ pulled pork sandwich ($5.50) that took my fancy. Trading in the temptation of a bulky burger for a healthier option, my American friend plumped for the smoked salmon wrap ($5.50). In an almost miraculous amount of time, a plate with two large wraps stuffed with tender smoked salmon, crisp leaves of lettuce, and chopped tomatoes and cucumbers arrived. Accompanying it was a light and creamy dill sauce that complemented the generously filled wraps perfectly. Both sandwiches came with a side option of salad, French fries, coleslaw or bacon potato salad. My fellow diner opted for the potato salad and noted that the potatoes were a tad too hard. Apart from that the combination of potato, bacon, black olives and herbs in a creamy sauce worked well with her wraps.
The pulled pork sandwich was definitely a good choice and the melt-in-the-mouth pork topped with home-made coleslaw and owner Jay’s sweet baby jay’s barbecue sauce came served on a soft, sesame brioche bun. The right amount of sauce also meant I could take my time eating without worrying about the bun getting stupidly soggy. The French fries were a nice surprise and came in the form of thinly sliced wedges cooked perfectly to the crunch, complete with a dash of herbs.
Happily full, we were tempted by the giant-sized cheesecakes ($2.95) calling from the cabinet. But sense took over and we vowed instead to return with plenty of space for cake.
Brooklyn Pizza and Bistro, #20 St. 123 (open Tuesday to Sunday, 11am – 10.30pm); 089 925926.